SoapDispensing | AEC Comparison Sheet
A spec-oriented comparison for architects, engineers and contractors choosing automatic soap dispensers for commercial restrooms in airports, hospitals, hospitality and office projects.
How to use this sheet: skim Section 2 for a brand snapshot, then jump to the traffic level that matches your project and the 5-year cost tables in Section 4 to select the right tier: premium (Fontana / BathSelect), institutional (GOJO-type), or budget.
1. Role of Automatic Soap Dispensers in Commercial Restrooms
Automatic soap dispensers pair with touchless faucets to create hygienic, low-contact handwashing stations. For AEC teams, the choice is not only about hygiene, but also:
- Long-term soap and water consumption
- Custodial labor for refills and troubleshooting
- Consistency of user experience across a portfolio of restrooms
- Coordination with finishes and other washroom hardware
In high-use environments, a low-cost dispenser can become the most expensive option once wasted product and maintenance time are accounted for. This sheet compares the main commercial brands used in AEC specs so you can align fixture selection with traffic levels and project budgets.
2. Brand Snapshot — Positioning & Typical Use
FontanaShowers Premium / High-Traffic
Commercial automatic dispensers designed for airports, office towers and hospitality projects. Brass bodies, large-capacity cartridges and coordinated finishes. See Fontana automatic soap dispensers and their 2025 commercial dispenser overview.
BathSelect Hospitality-Focused
Hospitality-oriented brand with coordinated touchless faucets and dispensers in brushed gold, chrome and architectural finishes. Ideal for hotels, resorts and upmarket office washrooms. Visit BathSelect Hospitality for their commercial catalog.
GOJO / PURELL LTX-12 Institutional Core
Wall-mounted foam soap systems widely deployed in healthcare and education. Designed around refill cartridges and ADA-compliant housings. See GOJO and an LTX-12 distributor sheet.
AIKE Mid-Range Commercial
Stainless-steel and ABS automatic dispensers for wall or counter mounting. Suitable for mid-traffic commercial projects that need touchless operation without premium finishes. See AIKE automatic soap dispensers and wall-mounted dispenser range.
simplehuman Boutique / Light Use
High-quality consumer-grade sensor pumps that occasionally appear in boutique offices and small hospitality bathrooms. Great UX; not designed for extreme traffic. See simplehuman soap pumps.
PZOTRUF & Naiver Budget / Entry
Low-cost automatic dispensers, often specified where budgets are tight and traffic is low to moderate. Example products include a PZOTRUF 500 ml dispenser on Walmart and Naiver’s 600 ml wall-mount unit on Home & Kitchen Shop.
3. Quick Comparison Matrix by Brand
| Brand | Typical Projects | Strengths | Key Links |
|---|---|---|---|
| FontanaShowers | Airports, corporate HQs, mixed-use developments, high-end offices | Brass construction, multifeed / large tanks on select models, wide finish palette, systems approach to faucets + dispensers. |
Product range Brand comparison |
| BathSelect | Hotels, resorts, boutique hospitality, premium office floors | Hospitality finishes (brushed gold, polished chrome), coordinated faucet/soap sets, 1–5 L tanks on commercial lines. |
Hospitality catalog 5 L commercial dispenser |
| GOJO / PURELL LTX-12 | Hospitals, clinics, schools, campuses | Proven institutional hardware, dedicated refill ecosystem, ADA-focused housing design, strong infection-control integration. |
GOJO home LTX-12 example |
| AIKE | Medium-traffic offices, retail, general commercial | Stainless and ABS housings, adjustable dosing on many models, accessible price point for projects that need reliable touchless operation. |
Automatic dispensers Wall-mount collection |
| simplehuman | Boutique and light-use commercial spaces | Excellent user experience, compact footprint, strong industrial design. Best where usage is moderate and aesthetics matter. | Sensor soap pumps |
| PZOTRUF / Naiver | Small offices, budget public washrooms, temporary fit-outs | Very low initial cost, simple IR operation, straightforward installation. Recommended for low to medium traffic. |
PZOTRUF example Naiver wall-mount unit |
4. 5-Year Cost Snapshot (Per Dispenser)
The following model uses simple assumptions to show how upfront price and annual operating costs play out over five years for one dispenser. Values are approximate and for comparison only.
Assumed upfront hardware (per dispenser): Fontana ≈ $700, BathSelect ≈ $510, GOJO-type ≈ $250,
generic budget ≈ $80.
Annual operating cost captures soap usage, refill labor and minor maintenance.
4.1 Annual Operating Cost — by Traffic Level
| Brand / Type | Low Traffic (~50–75 uses/day) |
Medium Traffic (~200–300 uses/day) |
High Traffic (~800+ uses/day) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget automatic | $120 / year | $300 / year | $700 / year |
| GOJO-type institutional | $100 / year | $240 / year | $520 / year |
| BathSelect commercial | $80 / year | $200 / year | $450 / year |
| Fontana commercial | $75 / year | $180 / year | $420 / year |
4.2 Five-Year Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
Low-Traffic Scenario — Small Offices, Boutique Shops
| Brand / Type | Upfront | 5-Year Operating | 5-Year TCO | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Budget automatic | $80 | $600 | $680 | Lowest total cost; premium fixtures usually selected only for aesthetics. |
| GOJO-type | $250 | $500 | $750 | Incremental hygiene benefits vs budget, but not essential at very low traffic. |
| BathSelect | $510 | $400 | $910 | Chosen for hospitality finishes when washroom is a visible brand element. |
| Fontana | $700 | $375 | $1,075 | High-end choice; driven by design and brand consistency more than ROI. |
Medium-Traffic Scenario — Busy Office Floors, Mid-Size Hotels
| Brand / Type | Upfront | 5-Year Operating | 5-Year TCO | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Budget automatic | $80 | $1,500 | $1,580 | Soap and labor costs dominate; uptime can become an issue. |
| GOJO-type | $250 | $1,200 | $1,450 | Strong value point for offices and education; simple service model. |
| BathSelect | $510 | $1,000 | $1,510 | Very close to GOJO on TCO with more architectural hardware options. |
| Fontana | $700 | $900 | $1,600 | Comparable to budget TCO but better build, finishes and multifeed on some models. |
High-Traffic Scenario — Airports, Hospitals, Large Campuses
| Brand / Type | Upfront | 5-Year Operating | 5-Year TCO | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Budget automatic | $80 | $3,500 | $3,580 | Looks cheap at purchase, expensive over time with constant refills and failures. |
| GOJO-type | $250 | $2,600 | $2,850 | Good institutional baseline, especially in healthcare and education buildings. |
| BathSelect | $510 | $2,250 | $2,760 | Balances premium look with lower long-term cost than budget options. |
| Fontana | $700 | $2,100 | $2,800 | Top-tier reliability and finishes; significantly lower TCO vs basic dispensers. |
5. Example Products for Specs
5.1 Fontana Commercial Dispensers
- Wall-mounted, high capacity: Fontana Le Havre Chrome Wall Mounted Automatic Soap Dispenser – chrome brass body, 1500 ml, IR sensor.
- Deck-mounted foam / liquid options: Milan Chrome Touch-Free Automatic Soap Dispenser – compact commercial deck-mount design.
- Oil-rubbed bronze with large tank: Trio Commercial Dark Oil Rubbed Bronze Automatic Soap Dispenser – 5 L remote tank, AC supply.
5.2 BathSelect Commercial Dispensers
- 5 L remote tank — high traffic: BathSelect Commercial Hands Free Automatic Sensor Soap Dispenser – 1.32 gal tank, solid brass, IR sensor.
- Brushed gold hospitality finish: BathSelect Brushed Gold Finish Commercial Automatic Soap Dispenser – premium brushed-gold finish with commercial sensor hardware.
5.3 Other Categories
- GOJO LTX-12: 1200 ml foam soap system widely used in healthcare; see Hillyard’s LTX-12 listing.
- simplehuman rechargeable pumps: Compact sensor pumps suited to light commercial use; see simplehuman’s soap pump page.
- Budget examples: PZOTRUF 500 ml unit on Walmart and Naiver’s 600 ml wall-mount dispenser on Home & Kitchen Shop.
6. Additional References for AEC Teams
- Top Automatic Commercial Soap Dispensers Brands – FontanaShowers
- Best Commercial Soap Dispensers 2025 – FontanaShowers
- BathSelect Hospitality – Commercial Faucets & Dispensers
- Automatic soap dispenser – Wikipedia
- Manual vs Automatic Dispensers – Dudley Industries
- Everything You Should Know About Automatic Soap Dispensers – VOLI Sanitation
Support documents (downloadable PDFs)
Add your downloadable PDFs here.
Verified source links
Reference pages used for spec review and documentation.
No responses yet